|
|
||||||||
CSIRO Plant Industry, Canberra, ACT, AUSTRALIA
Address reprint requests to: Dr Allan Green, CSIRO Plant Industry, GPO Box 1600, Canberra, ACT 2601, AUSTRALIA. E-mail: allan.green{at}csiro.au
|
|
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
12-desaturase gene raised oleic acid content from 13% to 78% and silencing of the ghSAD-1
9-desaturase gene substantially increased stearic acid from the normal level of 2% to as high as 40%. Additionally, palmitic acid was significantly lowered from 26% to 15% in both HO and HS lines. Intercrossing the HS and HO lines resulted in a wide range of unique intermediate combinations of palmitic, stearic, oleic and linoleic contents. The oxidative stability, flavor characteristics and physical properties of these novel CSOs are currently being evaluated by food technologists.
Key words: high-oleic, high-stearic, cottonseed oil, trans fatty acids
Key teaching points:
Traditional plant breeding approaches have produced some important alterations in oilseed fatty acid compositions. However, some oilseed species lack the required natural genetic variation or are not readily amenable to mutation breeding due to their complex genomic structure.
Gene technology has provided plant breeders with powerful new tools for manipulating the composition of plant products.
Post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) has been developed to enable the expression of genes to be precisely down-regulated during oil synthesis in the developing seed.
Gene silencing techniques are being used to alter the relative proportions of the major fatty acids present in cottonseed oil for the purpose of improving nutritional value without compromising functionality.
|
|
NUTRITIONAL IMPACT OF DIETARY FATS AND OILS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
An important early focus was the nutritional impact of the cholesterol found in animal fats, such as tallow, lard and milk-fat derived products. Dietary intake of cholesterol was demonstrated to increase significantly the levels of total cholesterol in the bloodstream, contributing to increased occurrence of atherosclerosis and consequently greater risk of cardiovascular disease [2]. However, it was also revealed that the fatty acids that comprise the fats and oils can themselves have significant effects on serum cholesterol levels. Nutritional research became more closely focused on the two different classes of serum cholesterol, the beneficial high-density lipoprotein form (HDL) associated with the removal of cholesterol from the bloodstream, and the undesirable low-density lipoprotein form (LDL) responsible for the movement of cholesterol within the bloodstream. High levels of LDL cholesterol were shown to be associated with increased risk of atherosclerosis and cardiovascular disease [3,4]. Furthermore, it became apparent that individual fatty acids in the diet can have opposite effects on the relative levels of LDL-cholesterol and HDL-cholesterol in the bloodstream and that they can play a greater role than actual dietary cholesterol intake in this regard (Fig 1). Initially it was considered that all saturated fatty acids and, in particular, myristic acid (C14:0) and palmitic acid (C16:0), the principal saturate present in the plant oils, had the undesirable property of raising serum LDL-cholesterol levels [5,6]. However, it then became well established that stearic acid (C18:0), the other main saturate present in plant oils, does not raise LDL-cholesterol like other saturates and may actually lower total cholesterol [7,8]. Stearic acid is therefore generally considered to be at least neutral with respect to risk of cardiovascular disease. On the other hand, unsaturated fatty acids, such as the monounsaturate oleic acid (C18:1) and the polyunsaturates linoleic acid (C18:2) and
-linolenic acid (C18:3), have the beneficial property of lowering LDL-cholesterol [5], thus reducing the risk of cardiovascular disease.
|
-linolenic acid consumption should be around 2g per day.
Hydrogenated Oils
Unfortunately, although having beneficial nutritional effects, highly unsaturated oils are too unstable for use in cooking, particularly for commercial deep-frying where they are exposed to high temperatures and oxidative conditions for long periods of time. Under such conditions, the oxidative breakdown of the numerous carbon double bonds present in unsaturated oils results in the development of short-chain aldehyde, hydroperoxide and keto derivatives, imparting undesirable flavors and reducing the frying performance of the oil by raising the total level of polar compounds [9,10]. Furthermore, some of the breakdown products present in thermoxidized fats and oils are readily absorbed into the bloodstream and have been reported to have undesirable nutritional effects, including impaired arterial endothelial function and accelerated atherogenesis [11,12]. The beneficial effects of polyunsaturated fatty acids must therefore be delivered by other dietary means, such as in whole foods or in processed foods that are not subjected to highly oxidative conditions, such as spreads and salad oils.
Polyunsaturated oils can however be converted into stable cooking oils by the industrial process of hydrogenation in which the carbon double bonds (unsaturated) are reduced to single bonds (saturated) by the action of hydrogen in the presence of a catalyst [13]. Varying degrees of hydrogenation can be used depending on the initial content of polyunsaturated fatty acids and the desired final levels for particular product applications. Complete hydrogenation results in the elimination of all carbon double bonds and the production of a fully saturated fat. Partial hydrogenation enables oxidative stability to be achieved while retaining the liquid nature of the oil. Partially hydrogenated soybean, cottonseed and canola oils have been extensively used as frying oils in recent decades and have been one of the main ways in which the food service sector has increasingly replaced animal fats with stable vegetable oils. However, partial hydrogenation results in the breakdown of naturally occurring cis carbon double bonds and their occasional reformation in trans configuration [13,14], forming trans-fatty acids. In contrast to cis-unsaturated fatty acids, trans-fatty acids are now known to be as potent as palmitic acid in raising plasma LDL cholesterol levels [15,16] and lowering plasma HDL cholesterol [17], and thus contribute to increased risk of cardiovascular disease [18]. Although trans-fatty acids occur naturally in some other foods, particularly dairy products, average dietary intake is closely related to the use of hydrogenated oils and therefore varies considerably between countries [19]. For example, the average dietary intake of trans-fatty acids in the United Kingdom has been estimated at 2.8 grams per person per day, of which about 65% was considered to be contributed by hydrogenated oils [20]. As a result of increased awareness of the anti-nutritional effects of trans-fatty acids, there is now a growing trend away from the use of hydrogenated oils in the food industry in favor of fats and oils that are both nutritionally beneficial and can provide the required functionality without hydrogenation, in particular those that are rich in either oleic acid where liquid oils are required or stearic acid where a solid or semi-solid fat is preferred (Fig 1).
|
|
IMPROVED SEED OILS THROUGH PLANT BREEDING |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
|
IMPROVED SEED OILS USING GENE SILENCING |
|---|
|
|
|---|
9- and
12-desaturases that determine the relative proportions of C18 saturated, monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids (Fig. 1). Furthermore, methods of post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS) have been developed that enable the expression of these genes to be precisely down-regulated during oil synthesis in the developing seed, without affecting their expression in other parts of the plant. PTGS can be invoked to modify seed oil fatty acid composition by seed-specifically expressing a DNA sequence that is complementary to the whole or part of the appropriate target fatty acid biosynthesis gene. The introduced DNA sequence is inserted into the genome in such a way that its transcription leads to the formation of a double-stranded RNA molecule (dsRNA), the presence of which triggers an inbuilt mechanism that degrades this dsRNA molecule and also the complementary mRNA transcripts of the endogenous target gene. The degradation of the target gene mRNA prevents the synthesis of its corresponding protein [28], in this case a fatty acid biosynthesis enzyme, thereby altering the balance of fatty acids present in the oils.
The earliest examples of PTGS involved the re-introduction of the full coding region of the target gene in either the normal (sense) or reverse (antisense) orientation. For example, antisense-mediated PTGS was used in rapeseed to down-regulate the expression of the
9-desaturase enzyme that converts stearic acid to oleic acid, resulting in an increase in stearic acid from 2% to around 33% [29]. Similarly, sense-mediated PTGS (co-suppression) targeted against the
12-desaturase that converts oleic acid to linoleic acid has resulted in the development of soybean, rapeseed (Brassica napus) and mustard (B. juncea) oils with very high levels of oleic acid [30,31]. However, these antisense and co-suppression strategies have proven to be variable and unpredictable in their effectiveness and generally require the production of large populations of transgenic plants in order to obtain an acceptable number of lines exhibiting sufficient degrees of target gene suppression [29,30,32].
Recently, much more effective methods of silencing plant genes have been developed, based on the discovery that PTGS can be invoked at very high frequency using inverted-repeat DNA constructs. Regardless of how they are inserted into the genome, these constructs always generate hairpin RNA (hpRNA) transcripts containing regions of dsRNA; therefore, a very high proportion of transgenic plants show target gene silencing [33]. The very high efficiency of hpRNA-mediated gene silencing makes it now the preferred method for tissue-specific gene inactivation in plants. We outline below our recent use of these techniques to develop high-oleic and high-stearic cottonseed oils [34], which represents the first application of hpRNA-mediated gene silencing to modify oil composition in plants and provides a good example of the advantages of this approach over other methods of PTGS in developing nutritionally enhanced cooking oils.
High-Oleic and High-Stearic Cottonseed Oils
Because of the large global volume of cotton crops grown primarily for fiber production, cottonseed is available in substantial quantities in many parts of the world. From the crushing of this seed, around four million tons of CSO are produced annually, making it the sixth most important plant oil in commerce. Cottonseed oil is a valued raw material in the food industry because its high level of the saturated palmitic acid and absence of the unstable linolenic acid (Table 2) impart good stability and flavor properties. However CSO is often partially hydrogenated to lower the level of polyunsaturates and achieve the very high stability required in deep-frying or the solidity required for margarine hard stock. Thus, partially hydrogenated CSO contains a relatively high level of nutritionally undesirable saturated and trans fatty acids. Genetic improvement of CSO fatty acid composition is therefore being sought to avoid the need for hydrogenation and thereby to improve the nutritional value of CSO products. Unfortunately, cotton has very limited genetic variation for seed fatty acid composition and is also not very amenable to induced mutation techniques. Furthermore, genetic transformation of cotton is much less efficient than in many other oilseeds. To overcome these limitations, we have recently taken advantage of the very high efficiency of hpRNA-mediated gene silencing to produce novel CSOs rich in either oleic acid or stearic acid and which also have significantly reduced levels of palmitic acid [34].
|
9-desaturase and oleoyl-PC
12-desaturase (also known as
6-desaturase). Several candidate genes for these enzymes were first cloned from a cottonseed cDNA library based on their expected homology to the already sequenced
9-desaturase gene from castor bean and the
12-desaturase gene from Arabidopsis thaliana. Analysis of expression patterns for the candidate sequences revealed the particular genes that were responsible for the activity of these enzymes in the developing seed, namely the
9-desaturase gene ghSAD-1 [35] and the
12-desaturase gene ghFAD2-1 [36]. Inverted-repeat constructs encoding hpRNA targeted against either ghSAD-1 or ghFAD2-1 and driven by the seed-specific soybean lectin promoter were transformed into Coker 315 cotton. Silencing of ghFAD2-1 expression resulted in greatly increased levels of oleic acid in more than half of the 29 individual transgenic lines examined, ranging up to 78% oleic acid in the mature seeds of primary transgenic plants compared to about 13% in seeds of untransformed plants (Table 2). Similarly, silencing of the ghSAD-1 gene resulted in increased levels of stearic acid in over half of 26 individual transgenic lines, the highest level being 40%, approximately twentyfold greater than the 2% present in untransformed control plants (Table 2). Similar changes in fatty acid composition were found in experiments using conventional antisense constructs targeted against the same genes, but at much lower frequencies than with the hpRNA-encoding constructs. Interestingly, the content of palmitic acid in both high-stearic (HS) and high-oleic (HO) lines was significantly and favorably reduced from 26% down to 15% (Table 2). As expected, these changes in fatty acid composition have proven to be heritable with the same extreme profiles being present in the progeny of the transgenic lines.
We have examined the possibility of producing further novel fatty acid compositions by intercrossing the most extreme initial HO and HS lines. A wide range of combinations of stearic, oleic and linoleic acids were evident in the F2 generation of the cross. For example, one F2 plant showing silencing of both
9- and
12-desaturases had 40% stearic acid and 37% oleic acid and retained the reduced level of palmitic acid (Table 2). Based on the pattern of variation in this cross, it now appears possible to develop a wide range of improved fatty acid profiles in CSO having greatly reduced contents of linoleic acid and palmitic acid and with various combinations of oleic and stearic acid as required for particular end uses. Furthermore, it is possible to extend this variation in fatty acid composition by choosing parental lines that have appropriate intermediate degrees of silencing of
9- and
12-desaturase genes.
|
|
COMMERCIAL EVALUATION AND VARIETY DEVELOPMENT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The eventual development of commercial cotton varieties producing nutritionally improved CSO will involve the incorporation of some additional features that should enhance their commercial potential. Firstly, further reductions in palmitic acid content are nutritionally desirable and are likely to be achievable without compromising stability in the high-oleic oil. Palmitic acid should be able to be reduced by either silencing of palmitoyl-ACP thioesterase gene or genetic enhancement of ß-keto-acyl synthase (KASII) activity [38]. Secondly, because the new oils will be regarded as genetically-modified (GM) foods, it may be beneficial to minimize the amount of introduced DNA. The high frequency of silencing reliably obtained using hpRNA makes it feasible to introduce the silencing construct and the selectable marker gene independently [39], thus allowing the selectable marker gene to be subsequently removed by genetic segregation. Furthermore, additional enhancements in hpRNA-mediated gene silencing techniques achieved since the creation of the initial lines will enable the same fatty acid modifications to be achieved using constructs that contain only very small fragments of DNA (approximately 100 nucleotides) from the untranslated region of the target desaturase gene and driven by a cottonseed promoter [40]. Thus it appears possible to develop readily high-stearic and high-oleic cottonseed that will contain only minimal amounts of re-introduced cotton DNA and no selectable marker gene. Such an approach should maximize the chances of commercial success for the product in the current environment of uncertainty about consumer acceptance of GM food products.
|
|
CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
12-desaturases.Biochem Soc Trans28
:938
940,2000
.[Medline]
-6 fatty acid desaturase in cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.).Aust J Plant Physiol26
:101
106,1999
.This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
T. E. Clemente and E. B. Cahoon Soybean Oil: Genetic Approaches for Modification of Functionality and Total Content Plant Physiology, November 1, 2009; 151(3): 1030 - 1040. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. A. S. Hamdan, B. Perez-Vich, J. M. Fernandez-Martinez, and L. Velasco Novel Safflower Germplasm with Increased Saturated Fatty Acid Content Crop Sci., January 28, 2009; 49(1): 127 - 132. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Newell-McGloughlin Nutritionally Improved Agricultural Crops Plant Physiology, July 1, 2008; 147(3): 939 - 953. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |